Author J.K. Rowling recently shared her unhappiness with the media. She spoke about how they reported the case of a transgender criminal by calling the individual involved a “she.” This comes after Rowling’s frequent public statements against transgender people.
Sky News’ Reporting
Rowling criticized Sky News for not saying that a convicted killer, Scarlet Blake, is a transgender woman. Blake was found guilty, and she will serve a life sentence in a men’s prison. Rowling criticized how gender identity is represented when the media reports crimes.
The Case of Scarlet Blake
Blake was convicted for ending the life of Jorge Martin Carreno. She pushed him into the River Cherwell in Oxford. During the trial, the prosecutors focused on Blake’s interest in death and harm. They spoke about her troubled past and identity struggles after moving from China to the UK as a child.
Rowling’s Response
On Twitter, Rowling wrote, “I’m so sick of this. This is not a woman. These are #NotOurCrimes.” She also previously claimed that trans women “retain male patterns of criminality.” Many people have criticized her for these comments, claiming that they are transphobic.
Sharing an Article
Rowling also shared an article from The Guardian, claiming she agrees with “every word of this.” Like Rowling, Louise Tickle, the writer, also criticized the media’s reporting of the news. Tickle claimed that it is wrong to call Blake a woman instead of recognizing that she is transgender.
Other Comments
Rowling also said, “1. Crime statistics are rendered useless if violent and sexual attacks committed by men are recorded as female crimes. 2. Activists are already clamouring for [her] to be incarcerated in a women’s prison. 3. Ideologically-driven misinformation is not journalism.”
Rowling’s Essay
Previously, Rowling published a 3,600-word essay sharing her concerns over transgender access to women-only spaces. She made a connection between it and her experience of sexual assault. She worried that “new trans activism” violates women’s rights to single-sex spaces by allowing predators to use them.
Public Figures and Actors Respond
Numerous actors from the Harry Potter series have previously shown support for the transgender community after Rowling’s comments on trans people. This includes Emma Watson, Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint, and others. They have spoken about how trans women are real women and that it is important to show respect for everyone’s gender identity.
Legal and Social Context in the UK
The Equality Act 2010 in Britain protects trans individuals’ rights to access single-sex spaces. This is part of wider anti-discrimination measures. However, the Act allows for certain exclusions to be made under extraordinary conditions. This has caused many people to question the relationship between human rights and safety.
Scotland’s Proposed Reforms
Rowling has also been concerned about legislative changes in Scotland. The Scottish government has proposed simplifying the process for trans individuals to change their birth certificates. Rowling claims that going ahead with these changes would undermine the safety of women and girls.
First Comments
This is not the first time Rowling has criticized the media. In 2020, she spoke about how the media spoke about “people who menstruate” instead of using the word “woman.” She has consistently spoken about the importance of recognizing biological sex and its consequences for women’s rights.
Thoughts on Trans Rights
Previously, Rowling did say she supported transgender rights and vowed to march with trans people in support of them. However, many critics claim her comments suggest a different story. She once criticized being called a “trans-exclusionary radical feminist” (TERF), saying that she wasn’t being hateful, although she later came to refer to herself as a TERF.
International Perspective
Several countries, including Ireland, Portugal, Norway, and Argentina, have created policies to allow trans people to legally change their gender more easily than in England. In these countries, trans people can do so without needing a mental health diagnosis. Trans activists have supported these changes and encouraged other countries to follow suit.
Kenya’s Supreme Court Ruling on LGBTQ+ Organizations
Kenya’s Supreme Court recently ruled in favor of the LGBTQ+ community. They allowed the National Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission to register as an NGO. This decision challenges the current criminalization of same-sex relationships in Kenya. It could lead to increased legal recognition and protection of LGBTQ+ rights in such areas.
Global Legal Advancements for LGBTQ+ Rights
Likewise, other countries have helped to protect LGBTQ+ rights. In Spain, the government passed legislation to make it easier for transgender individuals to have their gender identity legally recognized. Similarly, Hong Kong’s highest court ruled against requiring transgender people to have surgery to change their legal gender.
Transgender Healthcare in the U.S.
In Alabama, the 11th US Circuit Court of Appeals allowed the state to enforce its ban on gender-affirming care for transgender youth. At least 22 states have laws restricting gender-affirming care for minors. However, federal courts have issued mixed rulings, while every major medical organization opposes these bans.
A Challenging Year
The Human Rights Campaign declared a state of emergency for LGBTQ+ Americans due to the rise in anti-LGBTQ+ bills. With 77 anti-LGBTQ+ bills passed into law in 2023, the community faces increasing challenges. There are numerous restrictions on transgender healthcare and attempts to erase LGBTQ+ presence from public life.
International LGBTQ+ Rights
Despite progress, around seventy countries criminalize homosexual activity. In some places, the punishment is the death penalty. In other countries, LGBTQ+ individuals face other dangers, including forced marriages. Transgender people are particularly vulnerable to violence in these places.
Thinking About Legacies
Several people have said that Rowling is ‘ruining’ her legacy with her comments. In response to this, Rowling said, “I do not walk around my house, thinking about my legacy. You know, what a pompous way to live your life walking around thinking, ‘What will my legacy be?’ Whatever, I’ll be dead. I care about now. I care about the living.”
20 Reasons to Reconsider Supporting Donald Trump
20 Reasons to Reconsider Supporting Donald Trump
Trump Descends Into Social Media Meltdown After Lincoln Project Faults Him in Ad
Trump Descends Into Social Media Meltdown After Lincoln Project Faults Him in Ad
21 Things Ruined by MAGA Followers, Affecting Us All
21 Things Ruined by MAGA Followers, Affecting Us All
21 Phrases That Out You as a Republican Voter
21 Phrases That Out You as a Republican Voter